Phil Fritts, Safety Director

Phil Fritts, Safety Director,

Town of Jonesborough

Mcrail exhausted all efforts to assist us, and went above and beyond in their efforts… thanks to your staff for the excellent customer service… the quality of service I received is a testimony to the type of organization you manage.

Richard Benck, Vice President investment & Risk Mgt.

Richard Benck, Vice President investment & Risk Mgt.,

Unimin Corporation, Winchester & Western Railroad

Bob and his team at McRail have been supporting our railroad's insurance and risk management needs faithfully for over 20 years.   Bob has been extremely helpful to me over the years explaining the nuances of the railroad

Craig R. Lefever, Vice President - General Manager

Craig R. Lefever, Vice President - General Manager ,

Strasburg Rail Road Company

For more than 15 years McRail has provided the Strasburg Rail Road with timely and informative quotes, institutional knowledge and education concerning the railroad insurance markets, and professional, courteous, and timely service for any needs that have arisen on our railroad.

R. Mark Bryant, CEO

R. Mark Bryant, CEO,

Buckingham Branch Railroad

We have used Bob McCarthy and McRail Insurance as our liability insurance broker for many years. We have found Bob and his team to be reliable and trustworthy advisors in railroad liability insurance matters. They advocate for us with the insurance company when needed and they work hard each year to find us the most appropriate and cost effective liability insurance.

Jeb S. Stotter, Vice President

Jeb S. Stotter, Vice President,

North Shore Railroad Company & Affiliates

Since 1984, we have contracted with McRAIL for all of our railroad insurance needs. McRAIL provides exemplary customer service and invaluable consultation to our six short lines. Simply stated, we consider McRAIL to be the premier insurance provider to the short line railroad industry.

Wayne York, Excursion Manager,


The Fort Wayne Railroad Historical Society, Inc. has been well served by McRail.   We operate a 70 year old steam locomotive pulling mainline railroad excursions with 700+ passengers all over the eastern US, on several rail carriers.  It is certainly a rare and unusual operation and McRail has given us outstanding service and advice.  Subrogation has been a critical issue for us and special arrangements have been made with Underwriters for a satisfactory solution. More recently, a status-quo Renewal in May 2015 would have resulted in a 10% rate increase for the FWRHS.  On their own initiative, McRail sought out an arrangement to split the coverage between two different carriers, almost eliminating any increase.  We can't say enough good things about the McRail team.   PS - I have been licensed as an insurance agent in Ohio for over a decade and even if I worked in those markets, I doubt that I could do as well as they have.

Wes Weiss, President & CEO

Wes Weiss, President & CEO,

Morristown and Erie Railway

Your first meeting with Bob at McRail will be a learning experience you did not expect or will ever forget.  It's like wall to wall carpeting, EVERYTHING gets covered.